Grammar schools…some thoughts

In the UK it is currently being discussed whether Grammar schools are going to make a re-appearance on the education landscape. The Prime Minister suggests that “The ban on new selective schools has been in place too long and has held bright poor children back” (more information on the government’s plans for grammar schools available here). This move to allow new selective schools to open is being couched as part of the governments plans to improve social mobility and ultimately social justice. Researching education, educational attainment or educational disadvantage is not my area of academic expertise. I am however deeply committed to education, the value it can bring to people’s lives, and believe that learning for pleasure rather than attainment should be encouraged. I attended a comprehensive school and then pursued my higher education through the university system. I’ve spent a long time in education, and I still love learning, that’s why I do the job I do.

In my current role and through the research I do, I often meet young men who have dropped out of school, for whom school has been a traumatic and fraught experience, young men who leave school unable to read, and young people and families who are living in some of the most disadvantaged and marginalised estates and communities. Bringing back Grammar schools is not going to suddenly allow those young people to thrive any more than the current education system. The idea that a child taking an 11 plus test from a disadvantaged community is on the same playing field as a middle class child, coached for the test is, frankly, laughable. Structural disadvantages exist long before children reach the age of 11. Child poverty is not solved by children getting through a test and into a Grammar school. Investment in communities and in the education system we have might be a better place to start if the government really are serious about social mobility. Maybe first however, the government should take out the dictionary and look up what social justice is, then they might see that Grammar schools are not the solution.

 

Advertisements

One comment

  1. christopherharpertill · September 9, 2016

    Yes! While May might believe in Grammar schools herself (no idea) this mostly seems to be part of a political strategy within the Conservative party and to get public support. I think educational researchers are generally in agreement that the reintroduction of grammar schools would be bad and most MPs are against them. But there are a small amount of right wing Tories like them. These are the people she has to try to keep sweet as they are likely to not be keen on whatever Brexit deal she (as a Remainer) proposes. Also, apparently public opinion has moved back to a positive attitude on grammar schools. It’s a bizarre world. The latest New Statesman podcast has some interesting discussion of this: https://www.acast.com/newstatesman/ns-171-affection-factionsandfandom

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s